Lindsey A. Motter

July 17, 1994 ~ March 9, 2024 (age 29) 29 Years Old

Lindsey Motter Obituary

Lindsey A. Motter, “Linny” or “Squish”, 29, of Pioneer passed away Saturday, March 9, 2024 due to complications from a tragic car accident. Lindsey was born July 17, 1994 in Bryan, Ohio to Pam (Lonabarger) and Scott Motter. She graduated from North Central High School and was employed by Reifel Industries in Pioneer.

Lindsey was a sweet soul with a huge heart who enjoyed thinking of other people and would give them small surprises or crafts. She gave the best hugs, had a great sense of humor and a witty way of making her point. Lindsey was strong, gentle and ornery all rolled up into one.  She loved the outdoors and all of its creatures; butterflies, bugs, flowers and all animals in general. Her favorite being kittens, especially her cat Penny, who will really miss her. Lindsey enjoyed fishing with her brother, and hunting. She loved aquariums and enjoyed going to the fish store with her dad. Lindsey also enjoyed collecting things: Mario Bros, cards, stickers, Pokeman cards and anything tiny.

Surviving Lindsey are her parents, Pam Motter and Scott Motter both of Pioneer; her brother and his fiancée, Coty (Paige Clark) Motter of Montpelier; boyfriend and life partner, Jess Webster of Hudson, MI; grandparents, Judy Nixon of Pioneer, Jim and Kathy Lonabarger of Pioneer and Marjorie Motter of Bryan; her kitty, Penny; as well as many aunts, uncles, cousins, other family and friends.  She was preceded in death by her grandfather, Jerry Motter; and great grandparents Harry and Alice Tressler.

A celebration of Lindsey's life will be held on April 20, 2024 from 2-5 pm at Lake Seneca Lodge, 233 Seneca Drive, Montpelier, Ohio. Memorial contributions be made in Lindsey’s memory to the Indiana Donor Network or to the Steuben County Humane Shelter. 

Lindsey believed in God and had asked Him to come into her heart. She had faith and always incorporated it into her life as well into others. Til we meet again our sweet dolly! Love you and will miss you so much!

To send flowers to the family, please visit our floral store.

Friends and family have shared their relationship to show their support.
How do you know Lindsey A. Motter?
We are sorry for your loss.
Help others honor Lindsey's memory.


Time to receive friends
April 20, 2024

2:00 PM to 5:00 PM
Arrow Head Lodge
223 Seneca Dr
Montpelier, OH 43543
Guaranteed delivery before the Time to receive friends begins


© 2024 Thompson-Geesey Funeral Homes. All Rights Reserved. Funeral Home website by CFS & TA | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Accessibility